First Birthday Gifts

Celebrate the big first birthday with our collection of thoughtful and memorable gifts for 1 year olds. From soft toys and keepsakes to sensory play and personalized presents, find something truly special to mark this milestone moment.

  • Milestone keepsakes & memory gifts
  • Soft toys & plush for 1 year olds
  • Sensory & developmental toys
  • Personalized first birthday gifts
  • Gift sets & hampers for turning one

Make their very first birthday one to remember with a gift that's as special as the occasion.

Skip to results list
5 items

Filter

  • Light blue turtle plush with a brown shell and cream belly sitting on a pink display pedestal.

    Turtle Plush Toy - Soft Stuffed Animal for Kids

    Turtle Plush Toy - Soft Stuffed Animal for Kids
    $12.99
  • Black, tan and white beagle dog plush with floppy ears standing on a round pedestal in a pink Present For Kids display.

    Puppy Plush Toy for Kids Ages 4–6 – Choose Your Breed

    Puppy Plush Toy for Kids Ages 4–6 – Choose Your Breed
    $12.99
  • Penguin Plush Toy Gift For Kids – With or Without a Rose

    Penguin Plush Toy Gift For Kids – With or Without a Rose

    Penguin Plush Toy Gift For Kids – With or Without a Rose
    $14.99
  • Sausage Dog Plush Toy for Kids Ages 7–14

    Sausage Dog Plush Toy for Kids Ages 7–14

    Sausage Dog Plush Toy for Kids Ages 7–14
    $15.99
  • Orange, brown and cream red panda plush toy lying on a pink display pedestal.

    Red Panda Plush Toy – Lying Stuffed Animal

    Red Panda Plush Toy – Lying Stuffed Animal
    $15.99